Poe’s Tavern, a unique Edgar Allan Poe-themed gastropub in Atlantic Beach, Florida, offers a distinctive dining experience featuring gourmet burgers, seafood, and a literary ambiance. Known for its creative menu items named after Poe’s works, the restaurant caters to various dietary preferences, including vegetarian and gluten-free options, while maintaining its focus on high-quality, flavorful dishes.
Edgar Allan Poe’s Ambiance
Stepping into this literary-themed gastropub transports diners into the moody world of Edgar Allan Poe. The interior decor features Poe-inspired artwork and literature-themed elements, creating a unique atmosphere that blends the macabre with cozy dining. Bathroom walls adorned with pages from Poe’s works add an extra touch of literary immersion.
Despite the dark undertones, the restaurant maintains a welcoming vibe with a sporty twist, featuring multiple TV screens that make it a popular spot for both literature enthusiasts and sports fans alike. The open-front design creates a beachy indoor/outdoor feel, perfect for enjoying Atlantic Beach’s coastal atmosphere
Gourmet Burger Highlights
Featuring ground in-house beef patties, the gourmet burgers at this tavern are the stars of the menu. Popular choices include the Tell-Tale Heart, Rue Morgue, and Gold Bug burgers, each creatively named after Poe’s literary works. The Amontillado burger, topped with guacamole, jalapeño jack cheese, and chipotle sour cream, is a standout favorite among patrons. For those seeking a non-beef option, the menu also offers chicken and steak alternatives for their signature burgers
Unique Seafood Offerings
Poe’s Tavern offers a diverse range of seafood options that complement its burger-centric menu. The restaurant is particularly known for its fish tacos, which are a popular choice among patrons. The daily Market Fish Sandwich special provides a fresh seafood option that changes regularly, catering to those seeking variety.
For salad enthusiasts, the Buffalo Shrimp Salad and Tuna Salad offer seafood-based alternatives to the traditional burger fare. The menu also features a Large Mahi Taco, which has received positive reviews from customers. These seafood offerings contribute to the tavern’s appeal as a versatile dining destination, especially fitting for its coastal location in Atlantic Beach, Florida.
Friendly Service Experience
Enthusiastic and knowledgeable staff contribute significantly to the dining experience, with many reviewers praising the servers’ passion for the menu and attentiveness to guests’ needs. The restaurant accommodates families well, offering highchairs and booth seating options for those dining with children. Despite its popularity, especially on weekends, the staff manages to maintain efficient service, with quick seating and order fulfillment even during busy periods
Vegetarian and Gluten-Free Options
Catering to diverse dietary needs, the menu features several vegetarian burger options, including the Veggie Black Cat, Veggie Raven ($13), Veggie Hop Frog ($15), and Veggie Rue Morg ($17). A vegan black bean burger is also available.
For gluten-sensitive diners, while there are no dedicated gluten-free buns, any burger can be ordered without the bun. Additional gluten-free choices include tortilla chips with pico de gallo and guacamole, fries, and salads (with modifications). It’s advisable to consult with staff about potential cross-contamination and the most current gluten-free offerings.